Listening to Jews


Latest News

Main Topics
	Jewish Community

	Israel

	UK

	Antisemitism

	Dialogue

	Jewish Law

	Environment

	Music

	Film

	Books & Arts

	USA

	Europe

	Dating

	Index of Topics

Other
	Newsletters

	Links

Advanced Search

United Kingdom

Listening to Jews
Keith Kahn-Harris

Discussed in this essay: Les Back (2007) The Art of Listening. Oxford: Berg Books.

Since last May I have been researching Jewish communal leadership in the UK since the early 1990s with Ben Gidley, my colleague at the Centre for Urban and Community Research at Goldsmiths College. Part of this project has involved an investigation into how Jewish organisations have used and commissioned social research. I have been impressed at the extent to which, broadly speaking, the Anglo-Jewish community has been research active in the last decade and a half. The Board of Deputies, the Institute for Jewish Policy Research and several other major Jewish organisations have commissioned substantial research projects and used their findings to shape policy. I myself owe my own current involvement in the Jewish community to this minor boom in research – in 1995 I was taken on by Jewish Continuity as a part-time research assistant, a position that gradually snowballed into my current level of involvement in Jewish communal life.

Inasmuch as research is a basic requirement for any community or organisation that seriously desires to understand itself and work better, the commitment to research shown by many communal bodies since the early 90s (and long before that in some cases) is admirable. At the same time though, it’s important to recognise the limitations of the research that has been carried out on Anglo-Jewry. The majority of the projects that have been initiated have been quantitative, based on surveys and statistics. There has been some qualitative research based on in-depth interviews and focus groups, but even these projects have had very specific policy goals. I do not want to disparage these kinds of projects (how could I? I was involved in quite a few of them) but it is striking that more open-ended research projects have been virtually absent in the UK. There has been little or no attempt to undertake observational social research projects that aim first and foremost to paint detailed and finely textured portraits of the way Jews in the UK live.

In reading Les Back’s new book The Art of Listening, it struck me just what we are missing. Les Back is Professor of sociology at Goldsmiths College and an expert on racism, urbanism and ethnic identity. I must declare a personal interest as he has been very supportive to me personally and a model of what an engaged academic should be. At first glance (hearing?) The Art of Listening is a book of little interest to non-sociologists, being a sustained meditation on sociological methodology and the art of social research. So why am I reviewing the book here? The reason is that Back has important things to say about the way we ‘listen’ to the world that are relevant beyond the sociological community.

Back makes a powerful case for sociology as ‘listening art’ that is well suited to ‘hear those who are not listened to and challenge the claims placed on the meaning of events in the past and in the present’ (1). Back summarises the importance of listening as follows:

Our culture is one that speaks rather than listens. From reality TV to political rallies there is a clamour to be heard, to narrate and gain attention. Consumed and exposed by turns, ‘reality’ is reduced to revelation and voyeurism. The central contention of The Art of Listening is that this phenomenon is having severe and damaging consequences in a world that is increasingly globalized and where time and space are compressed. Listening to the world is not an automatic faculty but a skill that needs to be trained. (7)

Both sociology and the everyday lives that sociologists study are shot through with both insight and ‘social deafness’ (11). Sociology may offer a systematic form of listening to others, but it is not capable of hearing all and knowing all. It requires a certain humility that ‘prizes patience, commitment to dialogue and careful and reflective claims to truth’ (20). For Back, this ‘commitment to dialogue’ means not only listening but also asking hard questions of the subjects of sociological writing, albeit in a respectful manner. He argues that ‘the political value of sociological work lies in being open to unsettling dialogues with humility’ (162). Above all, sociology offers hope in the possibilities of listening and dialogue.

The bulk of The Art of Listening consists of demonstrations of the author’s commitment to hearing and to dialogue, with a number of chapters reflecting on particular aspects of his research. Back ‘listens to’ such topics as the Immigration and Nationality Directorate in Croydon, young people’s feelings of safety and of home in East London, tattooing and the July 7 bombings. Throughout the book he draws on personal experience, particular that of the death of his father, but in a way that is never self-indulgent. Rather, there is a continual attempt to understand to draw connections between personal experiences and that of the other.

The book brought home to me just what has been lacking in social research on Anglo-Jewry. For all that all research projects since the early 90s have been initiated in order to ‘understand’ British Jews, it is a thin kind of understanding that has been achieved. Most research projects have been tied into very specific policy goals. The desire for ‘data’ in the pursuit of policy can force research into a straightjacket in which the subjects of research are only half-listened to – only that which is ‘relevant’ to the research gets heard. One of the problems of policy-oriented research is that starting with a view of what the subjects of research should be doing can lead to a certain lack of respect for them. This is a real dilemma in, for example, policy-oriented research on Jewish education. In the research on ‘moderately engaged’ British Jews that Steven Cohen and I carried out for the United Jewish Israel Appeal a few years ago (published as Beyond Belonging 2004), I hope that we managed to do justice to the dignity and complexity of our respondents; but I also worry that the desire for a more committed, engaged and educated population of British Jews might have led us to overlook some of the complex textures of peoples’ lives. Attention to what Les Back calls ‘interpretation without legislation’ (1) might have instilled in us a more creative and humanistic attitude to research.

Perhaps then the value of social research isn’t just its ‘pay offs’ for policy makers, but as a valuable exercise in its own right. Perhaps it can teach us how to listen to others in a more systematic and open way. Perhaps social research should be a more formal version of what we should be doing anyway. It is here that The Art of Listening gave me most pause for thought. It made me realise once again just how poor British Jews are at listening to each other. I’m always struck by this on my visits to Finland and Sweden – countries I love dearly – where it is rare to interrupt anyone when they are talking and listeners usually pause for a second or two before responding. I always find this hard to adapt to and until I adjust I feel crass and rude. The Jewish community (not just in the UK) is full of noise and clamour, we eschew silence. Think of how the standard way of studying Talmud is in a crowded Beth Midrash in which the student and hevrutah partner part-chant, part-talk across and around each other. Our culture of noise isn’t necessarily a bad thing; it makes for an atmosphere that can be wonderfully warm and vibrant. But the dark side is that the clamour to make oneself heard can lead to frustration and this frustration can lead to an increasing shrillness. The ‘still small voice’ can be drowned out; the voice of the marginalised can be suppressed. The recent controversy over Independent Jewish Voices is an example of how the desire to be heard can erupt in exchanges that are vituperative in their bitterness.

Perhaps then the major value of research in the UK Jewish community is as an exercise that can, potentially at least, force us to listen more clearly. We do not need to silence ourselves to do this in an illusory attempt at ‘objectivity’, but we do need to leave space for the other to be heard. Anyone with an interest in how to do this would be well advised to consult The Art of Listening as a treasury of good practice.

August 2007

Comments:

VIAGRA by: Buy Viagra @ 09:33:52 pm on June 21, 2008.

Buyaviagra.net - viagra is used to treat impotence in men. Viagra increases the body\'s ability to achieve and maintain an erection during sexual stimulation. Viagra does not protect you from getting sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV. Boost your Sexual night with long lasting sex with VIAGRA. www.buyaviagra.net

cialis by: cialis @ 12:15:54 am on June 28, 2008.

cialis
http://technorati.com/posts/tag/Buy+Cialis+Online.+FDA+Approved+Quality+Pills.+cialisxl
[url=http://technorati.com/posts/tag/Buy+Cialis+Online.+FDA+Approved+Quality+Pills.+cialisxl]cialis[/url]
levitra
http://technorati.com/posts/tag/Buy+Genuine+Levitra+Online.+FDA+Approved+Pharmacy.+xlevitraonline
[url=http://technorati.com/posts/tag/Buy+Genuine+Levitra+Online.+FDA+Approved+Pharmacy.+xlevitraonline]levitra[/url]

Acomplia by: Acomplia @ 10:22:49 pm on July 4, 2008.

Acomplia (rimonabant) is an anti-obesity drug. It was approved for marketing in the European Union in June 2006. Rimonabant is not yet approved for use in the United States, where it is known as Zimulti. www.acompliaonline.com

penis enlargement by: penis enlargement @ 03:35:10 pm on August 3, 2008.

American largest natural herbal health care products reviews for men and women health, general and sexual health, skin care and weight loss and much much more at free shipping in america with lowest price ever! www.gordoniihoodia.net

Acomplia by: Acomplia @ 02:35:57 am on August 16, 2008.

Generic Acomplia is an Anti Obesity Drug that is Best Weight loss product in UK and Europe. www.genericacomplia.us

penis enlargement by: penis enlargement @ 11:59:06 pm on September 1, 2008.

Penis enlargement products reviews for penis size enlargement by world\'s best natural herbal penis enlargement products like (penis pills, penis patches, penis devices, penis exercises and penis pumps) for increase penis size in girth and length in weeks with more harder and solid erections at www.penissizeenlargement.net

Breast enlargement by: Breast enlargement @ 01:14:04 pm on September 8, 2008.

Breast enlargement products that gives you fuller, firmer, larger, rounder perfect cup size breast in few weeks which increase the beauty of your body and gives you full confidence! www.big-breast-enlargement.com

http://www.penisenlargementmedicines.com by: Penis Enlargement @ 03:08:08 am on September 23, 2008.

penis enlargement medicines to enlarge penis size naturally with world\'s best penis enlargement techniques, solutions and methods that enlarge penis size, boost sexual life and gives you confidence. www.penisenlargementmedicines.com

cialis by: cialis @ 01:32:55 am on October 10, 2008.

penis enlargement by: Penis Enlargement @ 07:29:13 am on October 21, 2008.

Natural Herbalz Online Natural Herbal Health Care Products Store providing all natural herbal products reviews on men\'s and women\'s health, skin and beauty products, sexual and general health, weight loss and diet for better health and better life style. www.naturalherbalz.com

cialis by: cialis @ 12:16:08 am on November 4, 2008.

http://www.naturalherbalproduct.com by: Natural Penis Enlargement @ 04:40:40 am on November 27, 2008.

American largest online natural herbal health care products reviews and medicines for all kind of health care treatments and solutions for men’s and women’s health, skin care and hair care, general health and sexual health, weight loss and diet from www.naturalherbalproduct.com

cialis by: cialis @ 01:36:51 am on December 2, 2008.

Penis Enlargement by: penis enlargement @ 11:30:19 am on December 15, 2008.

100% Penis Enlargement is possible by Pills like VigRX Plus , Magna RX , Natural Gain Plus , Prosolution Pills And Devices Like SizeGenetics & Proxtender are only available at http://www.penisenlargementv.com

http://www.naturalherbalproduct.com/penis-enlargement-pills.html by: Penis enlargement pills @ 11:15:03 pm on December 15, 2008.

Natural Herbal product Online Natural Herbal Health Care Products Store providing all natural herbal products reviews on men’s and women’s health, skin and beauty products, sexual and general health, weight loss and diet for better health and better life style. http://www.naturalherbalproduct.com/penis-enlargement-pills.html

penis enlargement by: natural penis enlargement @ 11:27:53 am on December 20, 2008.

Naturalherbalproductz.com Shop for Men\'s & Women\'s health, Penis Enlargement, Acomplia & Breast enhancement, Skin Care, General & Sexual products, Weight loss & Diet supplements at http://www.naturalherbalproductz.com

penis enlargement by: penis enlargement @ 07:29:57 am on December 25, 2008.

Natural Herbalz - We Care Your Health
An America\'s Best Online Natural herbal health care products Review Store On Mens and Womens health, Skin Care, General Health, Sexual Health, Hair Care, Weight loss and More Health Care products, Treatments, Articles and Information. www.naturalherbalz.com

Natural Penis Enlargement by: Natural Penis Enlargement @ 07:20:38 am on January 3, 2009.

cialis by: cialis @ 02:06:50 am on January 9, 2009.

Natural Penis Enlargement by: Natural Penis Enlargement @ 12:17:19 am on January 12, 2009.

Natural Penis Enlargement by: Natural Penis Enlargement @ 12:08:43 am on January 14, 2009.

penis enlargement by: penis enlargement @ 08:05:13 am on January 18, 2009.

hoodia gordonii by: hoodia gordonii @ 07:17:45 am on January 20, 2009.

Hello, i am glad to read the whole content of this blog and am very excited and happy to say that the webmaster has done a very good job here to put all the information content and information at one place, i will must refer this information with reference on my website i.e www.gordoniihoodia.net

http://www.naturalherbalproduct.com by: Natural Penis Enlargement @ 02:18:35 am on January 24, 2009.

Natural Penis Enlargement by: Natural Penis Enlargement @ 02:25:51 am on January 24, 2009.

hoodia gordonii by: hoodia gordonii @ 12:13:18 am on January 26, 2009.

Herbal products by: Herbal products @ 01:17:46 pm on January 27, 2009.

We provides best natural herbal health care products and reviews on mens health, womens health, general health, sexual health, skin care, oral care, vitamins and nutrition, colon health and beauty products at www.herbalproductsreview.com

enlargement by: pills @ 03:57:59 am on February 9, 2009.

best penis enlargement products for natural penis enlargement available at
http://www.penisenlargementv.com

pills by: penis enlargement @ 10:49:03 pm on February 10, 2009.

Permanent penis enlargement pills stimulate development of the erectile chambers internally, allowing for a lot more blood to be held, thus giving a much longer and thicker erection.
http://www.penisenlargementv.com

http://www.naturalherbalproduct.com by: penis enlargement @ 11:44:14 pm on February 12, 2009.

I enjoyed to be at here because one of my point has been cleared here.
Blogs are becoming the main source of knowing about things certainty,its
importance,idolizing,either in a marketing way that one can differentiate.
http://www.naturalherbalproduct.com

cialis by: cialis @ 01:15:05 am on February 14, 2009.

penis by: naturalpenisenlargement @ 12:06:44 am on February 18, 2009.

Penis Enlargement products like penis enlargement pills, penis patches, penis exercises and penis enlargement devices for natural penis size enlargement.

http://www.naturalherbalproduct.com by: penis enlargement @ 10:14:54 pm on February 22, 2009.

I am glad to post my views and points in this blog, but I must say that webmaster of this blog has done a very great job to make his blog more informative and more discussable but unfortunately everything is same here that more than 80% in this and other blogs post their comments for making spam!!!, so i will really all this spam links to google band tool, because webmaster makes blogs for making discuss and for sloving each other problems. thanks
http://www.naturalherbalproduct.com

http://www.naturalherbalproduct.com/viagra.html by: Vigrx plus and Viagra @ 12:12:54 am on February 23, 2009.

“Try free vigrax plus, viagra, and all other top 2008 male enhancement products for erectile dysfuction, premature ejaculation, for FREE for 20 days.NO SIGNUP required.NO SPAM.NO handling rates.Delievering within a week.Available only for USA, CANADA , UK, GERMNY SWISZERLAND, UAE, AFRICA, JAPAN, CHINA, SOUTH AFRICA and Brazil. There u go. http://www.naturalherbalproduct.com/viagra.html

weightlossproduct by: weight loss @ 04:56:25 am on March 7, 2009.

lose weight feel great. Lose those extra pounds to look the perfect bikini shape this summer. got no day time? Adjust it in your beauty sleep time. try the all new line of weight loss products to give u the shape u always wanted.

http://www.weightlossproductz.com

weightlossproduct by: weightlossproduct @ 08:23:15 am on March 8, 2009.

interesting productz in the market at more convienient and cheaper rates and also without any side effects...
http://www.weightlossproductz.com

cialis by: cialis @ 03:53:16 am on March 12, 2009.

Penis Enlargement by: Penis Enlargement @ 01:40:39 pm on March 12, 2009.

Online Pharmacy with FDA Approved Generic Viagra, Natural Gain Plus, Enlast Formula, Virility Ex Pills, Acnezine, Natural Pain Relief, Hoodia Gordonii, Breast Actives, Lip Plumper, Anti Aging Solution, Acnezine, Acne Spot Treatment at Lowest Prices. Visit : http://www.theherbalproducts.com

weightloss by: weight loss product @ 04:01:10 am on March 19, 2009.

interesting productz in the market are launched with cheaper rates and also without any side effects

http://www.weightlossproductz.com

weight loss by: weight loss product @ 01:51:23 am on March 24, 2009.

interesting productz in the market are launched with cheaper rates and also without any side effects.

http://www.weightlossproductz.com

generic viagra by: generic viagra @ 03:12:36 am on March 24, 2009.

generic viagra
http://www.viagra2000.com/
[url=http://www.viagra2000.com/]generic viagra[/url]

propecia by: propecia @ 01:59:34 am on April 13, 2009.

propecia
http://www.propeciainfo.com/
[url=http://www.propeciainfo.com/]propecia[/url]

Penis Enlargement by: Penis Enlargement @ 06:05:40 pm on April 24, 2009.

Penis enlargement products, American Most Trustworthy Natural herbal product store for penis enlargement,Which increase your size 4-6 inches, Double the size Double the fun.(Yes No Pain ALL Gain) And more productslike weight loss, male enhancement, skin care, acne solutions, breast enlargement, hairLoss for men and women , multi Vitamin for men and women, optimum Diabetics, eazol Pain Relief , stretch mark prevention, revitol skin brightener, revitol hair removal cream, revitol anti-aging solution.This blog is very informative and thanks for the updates and the blog colour and desiging is very beautiful after seeing this u must be a creative man
http://www.penisenlargementinc.com

Penis Enlargement by: Penis Enlargement @ 04:01:43 am on May 1, 2009.

American Online Pharmacy with FDA Approved Generic Viagra, Natural Gain Plus, Enlast Formula, Virility Ex Pills, Acnezine, Natural Pain Relief, Hoodia Gordonii, Breast Actives, Lip Plumper, Acnezine, Acne Spot Treatment at Lowest Prices. Visit : http://www.theherbalproducts.com

http://www.bestpenisproducts.com by: Penis Enlargement Pills @ 02:18:57 am on May 9, 2009.

penis enlargement pills products reviews like vigrx plus, vimax, prosolution, penis enlargement extenders, devices and penis enlargement pumps that enlarge penis size naturally up 3-4 inch in a month. http://www.bestpenisproducts.com

PENIS ENLARGEMENT PILLS by: Penis Enlargement Pills @ 02:28:59 am on May 9, 2009.

generic propecia by: generic propecia @ 02:13:17 am on May 20, 2009.

generic propecia
http://www.propeciainfo.com/
[url=http://www.propeciainfo.com/]generic propecia[/url]

Vimax by: Vimax @ 01:13:54 pm on May 22, 2009.

60 Day Money Back Guarantee! Vimax is safe and natural penis enlargement pills permanently enlarge your penis size up to 3-4 Inches in length and up to 25% in girth risk-free. Just $39.15 per bottle

Buy Viagra by: Buy Viagra @ 01:06:30 am on June 4, 2009.

Buy viagra
http://www.viagra2000.com/
[url=http://www.viagra2000.com/]Buy Viagra[/url]

Penis Enlargement Pills by: Penis Enlargement Pills @ 11:08:17 am on June 26, 2009.

Vimax, Vigrx Plus, and Prosolution may be up best penis enlargement pills available, and can increase the size of the penis between 3-4 inches with as little as 2 weeks. http://www.pill-penisenlargement.com

Penis Enlargement by: Penis Enlargement @ 11:12:32 am on June 26, 2009.

Penis enlargement products reviews for penis size enlargement by world’s best natural herbal penis enlargement products like (penis pills, penis patches, penis devices, and penis exercises ) for increase penis size in girth and length in weeks with more harder and solid erections at http://www.bestpenisproducts.com

QUICKLINKS

Bitter Lemons

Gesher

Jewish Dialogue Group

Limmud

Ta Shma

Tzohar

RECOMMENDED BLOG AND ONLINE PUBLICATIONS

Site sponsored by

United Kingdom